Aston Villa manager Gerard Houllier unlikely to return to full-time managerial duties this season
Gérard Houllier is unlikely to resume full-time managerial duties at Aston Villa this season after being admitted to hospital complaining of chest pains.
Chest pains: Aston Villa manager Grd Houllier is unlikely to return to full-time managerial duties this season after being admitted to hospital Photo: GETTY IMAGES
By Sandy Macaskill 10:54PM BST 21 Apr 2011
Follow Sandy Macaskill on Twitter
Comments
Villa, who are seven points clear of the relegation zone, will not be rushed into making a decision over his future, but they have conceded that the 63 year-old needs rest in the wake of a serious health scare.
Houllier was being examined at the Queen Elizabeth Hospital in Birmingham on Thursday night, where he was described as “comfortable” and “very positive”. However, medical staff have been unable to give any definitive prognosis on his condition and he is expected to remain under observation for a few days while further tests take place.
In the meantime, Gary McAllister, his assistant, has been given control of team affairs. The Scotsman took charge of training Thursday and will be accompanied by Gordan Cowans in the technical area for the club’s home fixture against Stoke City Saturday. The club will bring in new personnel only in the unlikely event that McAllister requests assistance.
McAllister visited Houllier Thursday afternoon, as did Villa chief executive Paul Faulkner, and was said to be in good spirits, and with plenty of colour in his face.
He is understood to have quizzed McAllister about the morning’s training session, and issued instructions for Villa’s preparation ahead of Saturday’s game. Nevertheless, there remains genuine concern for his wellbeing.
The Frenchman began feeling unwell at around 7pm on Wednesday, before chest pains forced him to visit the hospital, scenes all too reminiscent of the heart problems he experienced in October 2001.
Houllier and his family are thought to be encouraged by the fact that he was not taken into surgery immediately on being admitted to the Queen Elizabeth Hospital.
When Houllier, then 54, suffered a condition known as dissection of the aorta at half-time during Liverpool’s 1-1 draw with Leeds in 2001, he was taken straight to surgery for an 11-hour open-heart operation. Surgeons repaired the main aortic valve with a synthetic material called Dacron — an operation with a success rate of just 30 per cent. Houllier later admitted that he was fortunate to be alive.
Houllier arrived at Villa Park seven months ago to succeed Martin O’Neill looking bronzed and healthy, and insisting that he was fit for the task ahead.
“When you go into this job there is pressure, hard work, you won’t sleep every night, so you need to make sure that your body is ready to sustain the challenge,” he said at the time. “But I would say I’m even fitter than when I was at Lyon.”
Houllier was referring to his two years, from 2005-07, at Lyon, who hired him to turn domestic dominance into European success after winning their fourth successive championship. “I would say that this was very demanding,” he said.
However, even a decade on from his operation, the Villa manager still meets regularly with his specialist, Liverpool Heart and Chest Hospital’s Dr Abbas Rashid, “on a friendly basis”. Rashid has even attended games at Villa.
Houllier is understood to have hesitated over accepting Villa’s offer of employment in September because of his wife Isabelle’s fears about what a return to the rigours of Premier League management might mean to his health.
There have been private concerns in recent weeks over Houllier’s ability to withstand the strains of modern management, and especially being embroiled in a relegation battle.
Although he has looked in good spirits at the training ground even when supporters have been calling for his departure, on match days he has looked increasingly fatigued, walking slowly from the technical area to the tunnel at the final whistle, and often arriving at his post-match press conferences out of breath.
What this means for his future at Villa remains uncertain. The club’s American owner, Randy Lerner, will fly to Birmingham for the Stoke game this weekend, and will visit Houllier, but they will not discuss the Frenchman’s future until his condition is made clearer by medical staff.
Until then, the message last night was that the future remains Houllier’s decision, and that he is still the club’s manager.
The players were informed of Houllier’s condition on Thursday morning. Stewart Downing, the England international midfielder, said: “Obviously, everyone at the club is concerned for the manager, but the news is that he’s going to be all right and that’s pleasing and reassuring.
Darren Bent, who Houllier signed for £24 million, said: “If we can win against Stoke, that will be one less thing for the manager to have to worry about. We want him to be able to concentrate just on his recovery.”
Pressure is all part of the job: it's how you deal with it
Steve Kean (Blackburn)
"It becomes more stressful if things aren’t going your way. I’m a big believer in making notes and looking at what is effective and what wasn’t effective. I don’t think you ever get away from it. It’s always been there [even as a non-manager]. I’ve always taken my work home with me."
Ian Holloway (Blackpool)
"It’s easy to label a football manager ill, but he is a human being and people must remember that. I don’t want to think football has done this to him. He is over 60. Lots of people get ill, and they are not football managers. I hope management has not played any part in all of this."
Mark Hughes (Fulham)
"This time of year stress comes to the fore. It’s a difficult job and we have to accept that. There’s a focus on managers and how their teams are doing. That demand falls on the shoulders of the managers. The LMA make sure we are regularly checked so we are strong enough to do the job."
Kenny Dalglish (Liverpool)
"The manager’s health is more important than anything else. There’s pressure on everybody in every walk of life. Different people deal with pressure in different ways. Each one is an individual and each one will find their own niche to combat it and it’s up to the individual to try and find a release for yourself."
Roberto Mancini (Manchester City)
"It is not easy. When you are under pressure you can have some problems. But I hope Gerard can get out of hospital quickly because he is a big person, a big manager and my friend. I hope he can be on the bench for the next game."
Alan Pardew (Newcastle)
"Comparing my earlier time in the Premier League to now, the emphasis seems to be much more on the manager and I don’t think that’s healthy or right. It’s about the clubs and the players, they’re the ones that should be discussed and it needs to be levelled out by the media I’ve not suffered too badly with stress."
Tony Pulis (Stoke City)
"Pressure is part of the job. Irrespective of what medical care you get, nothing stops you from getting excited on the touchline or carrying the pressure on your shoulders if things aren’t going well. Gary McAllister works closely with Gerard so there shouldn’t be too much disruption."
Steve Bruce (Sunderland)
"Pressure is only what you put on yourself. The only thing I’m scared of in my life is failure. That’s what keeps me going – the fear of failure. I’m used to pressure. I’ve been managing at this level for 10 years. It’s how you respond and react and get out of it. Only your team can do that for you."
Telegraph.feedsportal.com